NexGard Plus vs Heartgard Plus: Which Does Your Dog Need?


Choosing a monthly parasite preventive can be confusing because products that look similar may provide very different protection. The right choice depends on your dog’s age, weight, health history, lifestyle, and exposure to fleas, ticks, and mosquitoes.

This NexGard Plus vs Heartgard Plus comparison explains what each chew covers, where they differ and what to discuss with your veterinarian before purchasing.


What Is NexGard Plus?

NexGard Plus is a prescription monthly chew containing three active ingredients:

It kills adult fleas, treats and controls several tick species, prevents heartworm disease, and treats common roundworm and hookworm infections. Under the current U.S. label, it can be used in dogs and puppies aged eight weeks or older weighing at least 4 lbs.

NexGard Plus may appeal to owners who want broad parasite protection in one monthly chew instead of giving separate flea, tick, and heartworm products.


What Is Heartgard Plus?

Heartgard Plus is a prescription monthly chew containing:

It prevents canine heartworm disease and treats and controls certain roundworm and hookworm infections. It is recommended for dogs and puppies aged six weeks or older.

Heartgard Plus does not kill fleas or ticks. Dogs taking it may therefore need a separate flea-and-tick treatment, depending on their risk and veterinary recommendation.


NexGard Plus vs Heartgard Plus: Main Differences

Feature

NexGard Plus

Heartgard Plus

Dosing schedule

Once monthly

Once monthly

Active ingredients

Afoxolaner, moxidectin and pyrantel

Ivermectin and pyrantel

Heartworm prevention

Yes

Yes

Flea protection

Yes

No

Tick protection

Yes

No

Roundworm treatment

Yes

Yes

Hookworm treatment

Yes

Yes

Minimum age

8 weeks

6 weeks

Minimum weight

4 lbs

Follow the veterinarian's weight range

The most important difference in the NexGard Plus vs Heartgard Plus comparison is external parasite coverage. Both products help protect against heartworm and selected intestinal worms, but only NexGard Plus also treats fleas and ticks.


When Might NexGard Plus Be the Better Choice?

Your veterinarian may recommend NexGard Plus when your dog needs protection against several parasites, and you prefer one monthly product.

It may be more suitable for dogs that:

  • Spend time in grassy, wooded or tick-prone areas
  • Frequently visit parks, boarding facilities or grooming salons
  • Have an ongoing risk of flea exposure
  • Need heartworm, flea and tick protection together
  • Are difficult to give several different medicines

Using one broad-spectrum chew can also make the monthly treatment schedule easier to remember.


When Might Heartgard Plus Be the Better Choice?

Heartgard Plus may suit dogs that mainly need heartworm and intestinal worm protection or already receive a separate flea-and-tick product recommended by their veterinarian.

It may be considered when:

  • Your dog already uses another effective flea-and-tick treatment
  • A younger puppy is not yet old or heavy enough for NexGard Plus
  • Your veterinarian prefers ivermectin-based heartworm prevention
  • Your dog does not need an all-in-one parasite product

Do not automatically combine Heartgard Plus with other parasite medicines. Some products contain overlapping active ingredients, so your veterinarian should confirm that the combination is appropriate.


What About Side Effects?

Both products can cause side effects, although many dogs tolerate monthly preventives well. Possible digestive reactions may include vomiting, diarrhea, reduced appetite or tiredness.

NexGard Plus contains afoxolaner, which belongs to the isoxazoline class. The FDA advises that this class has been associated with possible neurologic reactions, including tremors, poor coordination, and seizures, even in some animals without a previous seizure history. Discuss this carefully with your veterinarian if your dog has experienced seizures or another neurologic condition.

Heartgard Plus post-approval reports have also included vomiting, diarrhea, lethargy, loss of appetite, and neurologic signs. These reports do not always prove that the medicine caused the reaction.

Contact your veterinarian promptly if your dog develops persistent vomiting, severe weakness, tremors, difficulty walking, seizures, or another unusual reaction.


Can You Switch Between Them?

Do not switch heartworm preventives without professional guidance. Your veterinarian may need to confirm the date of the previous dose and perform a heartworm test before recommending a new product.

Heartworm preventives do not treat established adult heartworms. Dogs should be tested for an existing infection before starting a preventive program, particularly if doses have been missed or the dog’s treatment history is uncertain.


Which One Does Your Dog Need?

In the NexGard Plus vs Heartgard Plus decision, NexGard Plus provides the broader range of protection because it covers fleas and ticks in addition to heartworm, roundworms, and hookworms.

Heartgard Plus may be enough when your dog already receives separate flea-and-tick protection or when your veterinarian recommends a more focused heartworm preventive.

Neither option is automatically best for every dog. Your veterinarian should consider your dog’s age, weight, medical history, local parasite risks, and current medications.

Once your veterinarian recommends the right product, select the correct weight range and follow the monthly schedule carefully. Explore genuine dog parasite treatments at 79pets.com and keep every dose recorded so your dog remains consistently protected.


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Best Selling Combo

Best Selling Combo

Heartgard Nexgard Combo for Dogs Flea, Ticks & Heartworm Treatment

Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 1131 reviews.

Customer photo review of Custom Duty

Fast shipping great quality and price

Custom Duty

Customer photo review of Revolution Plus For Medium Cats 5.6-11 lbs (2.6-5kg)

Two sweet girlies decided to make our deck their home. Mosquitoes are a big problem where we live and we had to get them protected. This was the best bang for the buck. I’ve ordered from 79Pets several times and while delivery is not fast it is very consistent.

Revolution Plus For Medium Cats 5.6-11 lbs (2.6-5kg)

Store owner replied: Thank You Teresa!

Customer photo review of Nexgard Combo For Cats 5.5-16.5 lbs (2.5-7.5 kg)

As a retired veterinary technician I was extremely happy to finally see a flea and heartworm medication that actually does tapeworms too!!!!!!! This is a 1st to my knowledge....I live in a tropical climate where fleas never die so this is heaven sent.

Nexgard Combo For Cats 5.5-16.5 lbs (2.5-7.5 kg)

Store owner replied: Thank You Kimberly.

Customer photo review of Stronghold Teal For Dogs 44-88lbs (20-40kg)

Very happy with the price of Stronghold heart worm med for my dog. Seems to be working well.

Stronghold Teal For Dogs 44-88lbs (20-40kg)

Store owner replied: Thank You Dory!

Customer photo review of Simparica Trio For Dogs 22.1-44 lbs (10-20 kg)

My dog loves this product, never got any issue. Good price , deliver on time. We will definitely keep purchasing with 79 pets.com. Thanks!

Simparica Trio For Dogs 22.1-44 lbs (10-20 kg)

Store owner replied: Thank You Elle!

Customer photo review of NexGard Chew For Small Dogs 10-24lbs (4-10kg)

I have 3 of these little rascals so Michigan flea/tick season can be financially brutal! Thank you for keeping NexGard so affordable.

NexGard Chew For Small Dogs 10-24lbs (4-10kg)

Store owner replied: Thank You Elaine

Customer photo review of Nexgard Combo for Cats 5.5-16.5 lbs (2.5-7.5 kg)

After Seresto collars failed to get rid of fleas, I didn't know where to turn. I saw a post on a page I follow (Kentucky Kitty Cats) saying that they use Nexgard Combo for the cats they shelter. I decided to try it and IT WORKS!

Nexgard Combo for Cats 5.5-16.5 lbs (2.5-7.5 kg)

Store owner replied: Thanks Cari.. We are glad that you found treatment which works for your Cats..

Customer photo review of Revolution Plus For Large Cats 11.1-22lbs (5-10kg)

This is Lexi Marie! She was wondering why mom was so excited for buying flea medicine. I explained to her that we saved $100 and that she would understand some day when she grows up.

Revolution Plus For Large Cats 11.1-22lbs (5-10kg)

Store owner replied: Thanks Tammy!!

Customer photo review of Revolution Plus For Medium Cats 5.6-11 lbs (2.6-5kg)

Last year, I made a visit to the vet. I told them that Kattie/cat had ear mites. They gave me an ointment costing $80canadian. I used it up and purchased another bottle. $160. total not including the cost of the vet visit. No results. The ear mites have been there for a long time. Canadian vets have control of what is sold in Pet stores and you cannot purchase off the shelf products not recognized by them. I jumped at the chance to purchase your produce with a recommended 100% effectivity. I was willing to try, but was suspicions. After a month there was still a little scratching but after 6 weeks, the mites are gone and the scratching is gone. Thank you very much for this mite solution. I recommend it heartily. Harry P.S. Do not tell the Canadian vets as they will outlaw your product.

Revolution Plus For Medium Cats 5.6-11 lbs (2.6-5kg)

Store owner replied: Thanks Harry for review!!

Customer photo review of Revolution Plus For Large Cats 11.1-22lbs (5-10kg)

En fait, c'est le seul produit dont mon chat "Winston" ne soufre pas de problèmes cutané et perte de poils, le "Révolution plus" fait très bien le travail, merci.

Revolution Plus For Large Cats 11.1-22lbs (5-10kg)

Store owner replied: Thanks Alain!